top of page

Online Ordering

Order online and make your cookies dreams come true.

Ready to order?

Pilgrim's Bakehouse Cookie Menu

Pre-order for pickup at Peninsula Country Market Saturdays 9AM-1PM

Chunky, NYC-Style 6 oz Cookies

6 oz cookies are the only kind of cookies there should be.

Howdy Pilgrim

Saddle up! This is our take on a cowboy cookie. Featuring a peanut butter dough with peanut butter chips, toffee bits and Special K all topped off with a thick layer of dark chocolate and flaky sea salt, it’s every peanut-butter-chocolate lover's dream come true.

CA$7.00

Howdy Pilgrim

Liz Lemon

Fresh lemon dough filled with smooth and tangy homemade lemon curd & topped with toasted meringue. "Good God, Lemon! - Alex Baldwin”

CA$7.00

Liz Lemon

S'Marvelous

Everything good about a s’more, in a cookie. This salted dark chocolate dough has marshmallows, graham crackers and chopped dark chocolate mixed in & all topped off with a large torched marshmallow. As Fred Astaire and Audrey Hepburn would say - s'wonderful!

CA$7.00

S'Marvelous
Featured

Bibbidi-Bobbidi-Boo

We couldn’t turn a pumpkin into a carriage, so we did the next best thing. Pumpkin spice cookie, toasted pecans, silky pumpkin filling, and torched vanilla bean meringue. Your happily ever after has arrived. Just eat it before midnight. "I'd say the first thing you need is... a pumpkin!" — Fairy Godmother

CA$7.00

Bibbidi-Bobbidi-Boo
Featured

Pie & Prejudice

It is a truth universally acknowledged that an apple pie is better with caramel. Oatmeal cinnamon cookie rolled in cinnamon sugar, stuffed with sticky apple compote, and finally finished with a generous drizzle of homemade salted caramel. A most formidable match, wouldn't you agree Mr. Darcy?

CA$7.00

Pie & Prejudice

Box of 4

Build your own mixed box of 4.

CA$25.00

Box of 4

Box of 8

Build your own mixed box of 8.

CA$45.00

Box of 8
bottom of page